Read our Google Reviews!

My insurance dealings with Magruder Insurance Agency has been & continues to be a 5 star experience! The agents & staff are all of the qualities that rate 5 star, quality, value, professional, & responsive. I say this emphatically because I was a principal in an agency in Pa. The values listed above were the main parts of our mission statement to our customers. RM Rockmore
Sandy Rockmore
Sandy Rockmore
00:55 14 Jul 20
Stephanie was awesome, within 24 hrs already had me homeowners insurance saved me so much time doing it on my own
18:22 13 May 20
I am very impressed with the level of integrity, professionalism, and courtesy Pat and her team provide their clients. Well done Magruder Agency - keep up the great work.
Scott Wilcox
Scott Wilcox
12:54 15 Apr 20
The entire firm is amazing. The firm provides exceptional service. Thank you for all that you do.
Minnie Galarza
Minnie Galarza
16:55 15 Dec 18
I had a great experience with Magruder Agency! I worked with Pat and she held my hand through everything! When I first came into the office, I was welcomed warmly and Pat was right out to talk with me. We went through more than one option on my auto coverage and she explained everything thoroughly. I ended up having to visit a couple of times with the different vehicles I have and she never lost patience through the whole process! She also walked me through the various ways to get discounts and save a little money. I will use Pat anytime I need insurance! She is not only easy to work with, but she is also a wealth of knowledge!
Wade Lucas
Wade Lucas
21:39 28 Mar 18
I want to thank Stephanie Van Slyck for her swift response to my request for a quote on homeowner's insurance. I moved to a new home and wanted some price comparisons for insurance. Stephanie quickly responded with 3 different quotes and presented documentation that my current insurance company was the most competitive. You provided me with peace of mind. My thanks to you and the employees at Magruder Insurance for your assistance.
Becky Koukol
Becky Koukol
17:06 27 Nov 16
I have dealt with Pat and her daughter for over a decade. As a small business owner I have appreciated their prompt and courteous service. They have always been there for me and offered solutions rather than dilemmas! They will find a product to fit your need, and work with you until you are satisfied. With so many insurance agencies out there, you have a definite choice, but only a few can offer the level of expertise Magruder excels at! Do yourself a favor and give them an opportunity to earn your business, they definitely will!
Horst Odparlik
Horst Odparlik
20:46 26 Oct 16
You will, no matter what, get service that goes above and beyond the norm when you work with the Magruder Agency. It is super apparent that they want to ensure that their clients get the products and coverage that we need. I really love working with them.
Margaret Perry
Margaret Perry
16:28 14 Jan 15
I have had the pleasure of working with the Magruder Agency for quite some time now. I admire Pat's kindness, empathy, and intelligence, as well as many of her other personal attributes. I appreciate her willingness and ability to set goals and consistently exceed them.
Charlie Goodwin
Charlie Goodwin
20:48 21 Jul 14
It has been such a comforting feeling having Pat and Stephanie take care of our insurance needs while we are out of town. They are always in constant communication with us whether it be phone or e-mail. We could not be more thankful for the Magruder Agency.
Colleen Goff
Colleen Goff
20:10 21 Jan 14
I asked my neighbor who insures her home, and she recommended Magruder Agency. I called them and had multiple quotes in hand within a day for my home and car. The quotes to my surprise were significantly less than then amount I had been paying for years with my previous insurance company. I would highly recommend Pat Magruder and the Magruder Agency.
Darrell Rodriguez
Darrell Rodriguez
14:49 05 Sep 13

The 3 Biggest Concerns 

people have when buying insurance are:


Cost of Coverage

Everyone has a budget and insurance can get costly. Most of the time, we receive lower, more competitive rates than you can when going direct. We also know how to handle your policies in the most cost-effective manner.


Being Properly Covered

The complexity of buying insurance and understanding the coverages can be overwhelming and leave people feeling uncertain. We ensure you are matched to the exact coverage you want and need, without using confusing insurance jargon.


Nuances of Filing a Claim

Even though we deal with more than 30 carriers, we work for you. This means we can assist you in the claim process, so you don't have to navigate it alone. We help ensure you understand your coverage and receive a fast and fair claim.
insurance agency financing

Our Mission

Our mission has never changed, which is to treat our clients to the highest level of service and professionalism as if they were members of our family.
insurance agency affiliations

Our Values

Our values are based on delivering dependable and honest service, while maintaining high respect for our clients.
insurance agency acquisition

Our Solution

As an independent agency, we are able to leverage multiple insurance providers to arrive at just the right coverage for our clients’ specific needs.
insurance service agreement

Get your coverage today


Still Have

Contact Us
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
insurance agency owner salaryMagruder insurance agency
envelope-oclosearrow-rightchevron-uptwitter-squarephoneellipsis-vfacebook-official linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram